Showing posts with label garth turner. Show all posts
Showing posts with label garth turner. Show all posts

Saturday, June 18, 2011

Blast from the Past

At the end of 2009 I had this exchange with Garth where he discussed how the Bank of Canada hiking rates would impact mortgage payments. He thought a 5-year fixed rate would be close to 7% as they move lockstep with the BoC. He had also argued there would be no more discounts available for some reason.
and that by this time a year from now BoC rate will be sitting at almost 1.6%, higher than today by 1.3%. That doesn't sound like a lot, but it puts the lowest VRM at 3.55% – which increases the monthly on a $400,000 loan by $300. A five-year mortgage would like go for close to 7%. Barn door. Horse.

#5 BearClaw on 12.16.09 at 9:47 pm

Garth,

I don’t think 5 year mortgages will be close to 7% with only a 1.3% increase in rates. 5 year mortgages are about 4% right now. An increase of 1.3% will put them at 5.3%.

There is a large spread between variable and fixed because there is some anticipation of rate increases priced in. So fixed rates may be less than 5.3% in this scenario.

Posted rate is 5.49% now at all majors. We are on the way back to 8% money in a few years. Get used to it now. — Garth

#7 BearClaw on 12.16.09 at 9:54 pm

“The first hike will be at least a half, and probably a full load. That could raise VRMs overnight by 1% “or a little more than 44%. Ouch.”

Garth,

For a 25 year amortization it would raise the *total* payment by 12%. The interest portion would increase by 44%.

A 1% increase on a 2.25% rate is 44%. I did not mention payments. — Garth


#10 BearClaw on 12.16.09 at 10:03 pm

"Posted rate is 5.49% now at all majors. We are on the way back to 8% money in a few years. Get used to it now.” -Garth

I think you know the difference between discounted and posted rates. But who cares? That’s not entertaining.

Kiss discounts goodbye as the BoC moves. That’s not entertaining either. — Garth

#11 Siberta on 12.16.09 at 10:16 pm

You ain’t going to win on this site BearClaw, get used to it. You recently purchased to, if I remember correctly.

#12 lgre on 12.16.09 at 10:21 pm

Bearclaw is learning that GT has every angle covered, dont bother trying to come from the back.

The ‘we are different’ theory is getting boring, nothing is different but everything is and will be the same…just wait for it.

18 months later a 5 year mortgage can be found for well under 4%. This is because fixed did not move with variable and discounts from the posted rate still exist. Two points I tried to make. Note how the blog dawgs mindlessly cheer on their leader as opposed to considering moderating arguments.

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Garth Turner Makes up Numbers

From It doesn't love us back:
(90% of new mortgages are for 35 years)
The CAAMP survey indicates this is more like 30%.


From Cowtown moment:
Exacerbating things was a recession which knocked oil prices down, increased unemployment everywhere (it’s now a chilling 10% in the GTA) and actually led to a decrease in Calgary’s population last year.
Calgary's population increased by 6,060 last year. There was a natural increase of 10,214 combined with a net migration out of 4,154.

Toronto's unemployment rate is 9.2%.


See Mike Fotiou's comment
See previous related posts here and here

Saturday, November 6, 2010

Garth on Jobs

But, this just states the obvious. The latest job numbers are terrible (3,000 new positions in the entire country, and a whack of those are ‘self-employment’).
Nov 5, 2010

Note that he omitted the gain of 47,000 full-time jobs offset by a loss of 44,000 part-time ones. Also he references that self employment makes up these new positions contrary to the report indicating 24,000 fewer self-employed positions.

While in this report Garth focuses on the headline number, in other cases he has selected different components which implying a deteriorating job market. However over this time period all of these components have been trending positive.


And today's jobs report shows the economy's still a dangerous thing, especially in Ontario. But, whadda I know?
July 9 , 2009


Hard to see how all this can happen when in a single month 53,000 people stopped looking for jobs, 45,000 more lost their jobs, and 35,000 made up jobs. Yet even with the official job loss number of just 45,000, we were in economic free fall compared to the States.
Aug 9, 2009


Last month Canadian employers terminated 139,000 full-time jobs, and created 130,000 part-time positions. So, those gains everybody was crowing about some weeks ago are pretty much gone, at least for now. And losing 139,000 steady jobs is a big deal – equivalent to the US shedding 1.3 million in a month, which would be a national disaster. Thank goodness some temporary or reduced-hours work was created.

Aug 8, 2010


A more serious analysis would consider all the different factors - not only the ones that portray a negative environment. Another thing to be cautious of in this report is monthly spikes that do not reflect underlying trends.


There has been a legitimate job recovery in Canada since July 2009, although it has not been robust enough to bring the unemployment rate to pre-recession levels. Total employment has fully recovered and wages have increased. The problem is this has been largely offset by a growing labour force.

Tuesday, January 26, 2010

I agree with Garth Turner

From Garth Turner's recent post (emphasis mine)

The main point is that real estate here is grossly overvalued and, as I’ve tried to underscore in the last two posts, the folks who don’t understand that are destined to relive the experiences of others. Yes, the market will be lower in a year or two than it is now, but I’m not expecting a 40% decline with foreclosures and abandoned blocks of McMansions. What happened in Vegas will stay in Vegas.

Nonetheless, Canadians will taste the bitter remedy of negative equity which has been forced down the throat of 23 million Americans. Those who bought most recently, at the highest levels, and with extreme leverage, are at greatest risk. The dangers we face have been well articulated here and will logically result in a 15% decline in the national average house price. In Toronto, maybe less. In Calgary and Kelowna, more. In Vancouver, may God be with us.

I think a 15% national decline is likely, especially with the price gains of 2009 considered.

Anyway, I was surprised to see such a mild nationwide correction prediction from Garth. I wonder how some of the blog dogs will react?

Saturday, November 21, 2009

The bubble model

The bubble model for home buyers in Alberta goes something like this:

A reckless financial illiterate buying simply for capital appreciation using the loan which allows for the minimum monthly payment.

For example this is from Garth Turners blog about how to tell you are in a housing bubble:
When the number of people taking 35-year amortizations explodes higher. Overall, these loans have doubled as a percentage of all mortgages in two years but that does not tell the true story, since today 5/35 buyers constitute an absolute majority of new originations. Of course, 35-year borrowers pay off virtually no principle for years and years which makes this akin to renting money. No equity means no ability to withstand a market correction.
From this mortgage market report 53% of new purchases are for amortizations 25 years or less. 29% are for 35 years or greater.

Another snippet from Garth's same post.
Some observers, bless their good hearts and large stones, had the courage to warn recent buyers with mortgages in the 2-3% range they could be in deep financial trouble before too long. But you know that. The reasons why have been beaten to death on this blog already.
To be fair in this case he didn't say that 2-3% variable rate mortgages are the norm. But going back to the mortgage report 5-year fixed mortgages are the most popular.

-73% of mortgages held by 18-34 year olds have terms greater than 4 years.
-71% of mortgages held by 18-34 year olds have fixed rates, 9% combination

Of new mortgages within the last 12 months shorter terms do appear more popular, but not the majority. 56% have terms greater than 4 years.

Of course there are a significant number of mortgages over 30 years at a variable rate and these will most likely cause some amount of turbulence during the next leg down. The model that typical Canadian buyers have been recklessly overbidding $300,000 for a shacks in downtown Toronto or Vancouver using a 35 year VRM makes for good entertainment but does not reflect reality.